An example of question drift (missing the point)

This entry explains question drift.

In a conversation or discussion, you have probably felt at times that “we’re not on the same page” or wondered, “why are they bringing this up now?” What is happening in those moments is question drift.

When question drift occurs, the conversation or discussion stops being productive. Let us learn what question drift is and how to prevent it.

Note that this entry does not explain “the question” itself. Since understanding question drift requires understanding the question first, please read the following entry if the explanation below does not make sense.

Let us begin.

toc

What Is Question Drift?

Question drift is, as the name suggests, what happens when the underlying question drifts out of alignment. Take a look at this example.

bear
Cars are necessary for society. They’re essential for transporting goods and people.
panda
Can you say that to the bereaved families of traffic accident victims?

The question has drifted in this exchange.

What do I mean? Let us analyze the question underlying the conversation.

Example of Question DriftUnderlying questionActual statementActual statementUnderlying questionCan you say that to the bereaved families oftraffic accident victims?Are cars necessary for society?Do you enjoy using sound argumentsto open people's wounds?The questions do not match→ Question driftCars are necessary for society. They are essentialfortransporting goods and people.

As you can see, the underlying questions in what Bear and Panda are saying do not match. This is what question drift is: when the underlying question is not shared among participants in a discussion, or when it changes without anyone noticing.

Keyword

Question drift: when the underlying question is not aligned, or changes without anyone noticing

Question drift mostly occurs during conversations and discussions, but be aware that it can also happen when you are thinking alone. You might find yourself, after a long stretch of thinking, considering something far removed from your original question — without realizing it.

Question drift goes by several related names in English:

  • Missing the point (the standard term in critical thinking)
  • Ignoratio elenchi (the Latin term, literally “ignoring refutation”)
  • Changing the subject
  • Shifting the goalposts (when someone changes the criteria mid-argument)

Of these, “missing the point” is the most established term in formal logic and critical thinking. The reason I prefer “question drift” is that it captures the dynamic nature of the phenomenon — the question drifts away over time — whereas “missing the point” describes a static state. Since both terms refer to essentially the same problem, use whichever feels more natural to you.

Deliberate Deflection

When a participant in a discussion intentionally shifts the question, this is sometimes called deliberate deflection.

I do not recommend dwelling on this distinction, however, because there is no way to definitively determine whether a question shift was intentional (unless the person admits it when pressed).

For example, the earlier exchange could fairly be called deliberate deflection by Panda, but there is no way to prove Panda is doing it on purpose. Since many people genuinely believe that responses like that are valid rebuttals, the practical solution is usually to end the discussion rather than accuse them of “shifting the question.”

This is also why I avoid terms like “changing the subject” or “shifting the goalposts” for general use — they carry an accusatory tone, implying the other person is doing it deliberately1. In my observation, most question drift happens unconsciously, and deliberate deflection is rare.

My recommendation is to think about this in three steps:

  1. Judge only whether the question has drifted — do not worry about whether it was deliberate
  2. If the question has drifted, simply point it out and realign the question
  3. If you are dealing with someone who drifts frequently, end the discussion (or do not engage in the first place)

This approach keeps the discussion productive without getting tangled up in motives.

Point

It is not worth speculating whether a question was shifted “on purpose”

Causes and Countermeasures

Now let us think about why question drift happens, and what to do about it.

There are three possible causes:

  1. Attention gravitates toward answers rather than the question
  2. Different participants have different ideas of what is “relevant”
  3. One participant’s position is fixed

Let me explain each.

Cause #1: Attention Gravitates Toward Answers

The first cause is that once humans start thinking, our attention gravitates toward answers rather than the question.

Once a discussion starts, people tend to set the underlying question aside and just say what they want to say (the answer). Before long, the conversation drifts, and the question that should anchor the answers has shifted without anyone noticing.

When you are discussing things with reasonable people, this is almost always the cause of question drift. When attention drifts away from the question, the question drifts.

Countermeasure #1: Write the Question Down

Flip this around, and the solution becomes clear: to prevent question drift, keep attention on the question. Specifically:

  1. Write the question where everyone can see it
  2. During the discussion, periodically check whether you have drifted from that question
  3. If you think the question should change, make the change deliberately (and tell the others if you are in a discussion), then rewrite the question

Of these, the most important by far is the first: write the question where everyone can see it. Unlike the inside of our heads, a written question does not keep changing on its own.

Point

To prevent question drift, write the question where everyone can see it

This is an important technique in any setting, but I especially recommend making it a rule in video meetings. In video meetings, it is hard to point out that “the question has drifted,” and off-topic talk tends to continue unchecked. When a discussion begins, display the question in large text on the shared screen. This alone will suppress question drift, and it also makes it easier to point out when drift does occur.

Always Be Aware of the Question-Answer Relationship

For a more fundamental countermeasure, stay conscious of the question that lies behind any answer — and explicitly refer to it (though this is easier said than done).

As a rule of language, there is a correspondence between questions and answers. Take a look at the following table.

Types of Questions and Their Direct Answers (Claims)Type of questionType of direct answer (claim)What should be done to achieve X?You should do Y.What is X?It is Y.WhyWhy is X the case?Because Y.WhereWhere is X?X is at Y (place).WhenWhen should X be done?X should be done at Y (time).WhoWho is X?X is Y (person).HowHow should X be done?X should be done in the manner of Y.WhichWhich is X, A or B?A. / B.BeIs A X?Yes, it is. / No, it is not.Do/Can, etc.Does/Can A do X?Yes. / No.OpenQuestionsWhatClosedQuestions

As shown, the type of statement that can serve as an answer is determined by the type of question. In other words, you can infer the type of question from the answer (what someone is saying), and use this to check whether question drift has occurred. You are working from the right side of the table back to the left.

In the earlier example, the four-column format makes this correspondence visible. Take another look:

Example of Question DriftUnderlying questionActual statementActual statementUnderlying questionCan you say that to the bereaved families oftraffic accident victims?Are cars necessary for society?Do you enjoy using sound argumentsto open people's wounds?The questions do not match→ Question driftCars are necessary for society. They are essentialfortransporting goods and people.

Bear’s side is a straightforward “infer the question from the answer” analysis. Panda’s side requires reading between the lines of what was actually said — a slightly more advanced analysis.

Since this four-column format lets you rigorously evaluate whether question drift has occurred, I recommend using it until you get the hang of it.

That said, most real-world question drift happens in spoken conversation, where you need to perform this evaluation quickly and instinctively2. Do not lose sight of that practical reality.

Cause #2: Different Ideas of What is “Relevant”

The second cause is that participants have different ideas of what counts as “relevant” to the question. This is less a cause of question drift than a different angle on it.

What do I mean? Let us continue the earlier exchange:

bear
Cars are necessary for society. They’re essential for transporting goods and people.
panda
Can you say that to the bereaved families of traffic accident victims?
bear
The question has drifted. “Is something necessary for society?” and “can you say what you think is right to those who would be hurt by it?” are unrelated.
panda
No, they are related. If something is truly necessary for society, you should be able to confidently say so to any member of that society.

Pointing out the drift did not work. On the surface, Panda’s reasoning even sounds somewhat plausible. For Panda, “whether you could say it to the families of accident victims” is relevant to “are cars necessary for society?”

Of course, the reasoning does not hold up, and the point is not relevant. Panda’s argument falls apart if Bear simply replies like this from the start:

bear
Cars are necessary for society. They’re essential for transporting goods and people.
panda
Can you say that to the bereaved families of traffic accident victims?
bear
Yes, I can. I don’t see why I’d need to, but yes.

However, even if Bear responded this way, you can imagine Panda would follow up with something like, “You’re a terrible person (bear).” This, too, is irrelevant, but because it feels relevant to Panda, the discussion will never converge.

Countermeasure #2: End the Discussion

The only countermeasure for this cause is to end the discussion (or not engage in the first place).

As far as I know, there is no established method for determining what counts as “relevant” to a question. Fields like logic teach you that “character and delivery are not relevant to a question,” but no field teaches you, in a universal way, what content counts as relevant. This part inevitably comes down to vague things like common sense, knowledge, and intelligence.

If you point out the question drift and your counterpart does not accept it, then those vague things differ between you and them. There is probably no way to align them, and it is certainly impossible to do so in a short conversation. Continuing the discussion is a waste of time.

Cause #3: One Participant’s Position Is Fixed

Finally, discussions with someone whose position is fixed tend to suffer from question drift.

The reason is simple: that person has no intention of changing their position. When the discussion turns in a direction inconvenient for them, they will try to deflect it however they can. That is where question drift happens (though it is still hard to determine whether it is “deliberate”).

Try reading the earlier exchange again, assuming Panda has no intention of giving up the position that “cars are not necessary for society.” Panda’s behavior starts to look like it has a kind of internal logic.

The countermeasure for this is also to end the discussion. “Having a fixed position” is the same as “not being open to discussion.” Engaging is just a waste of time.

Exercise

Question

Analyze the following exchange and explain how the question has drifted.

bear
Is this actually legal?
panda
Everyone’s doing it, so it’s fine.

Write your answer in the form below before checking the sample answer.

Bear’s question is “Is this action legal?” while Panda’s question is “Are many people doing this action?” The questions are different — the question has drifted.

Just because everyone is doing something does not mean it is legal.

That is it for question drift. Next, let us look at one specific form of question drift: the ad hominem fallacy. Read the entry below.

You can also find a full list of fallacy types (logical fallacies and cognitive biases) in the entry below.

Footnotes

  1. Even the original Latin term, “ignoratio elenchi,” carries no nuance of deliberateness. As far as I can tell, it simply means “not knowing how to argue” or “missing the point of the discussion.” ↩

  2. Personally, I suspect this ability — “instantly grasping the relationship between question and answer” — is at the core of what is called “language skills” or “communication ability.” ↩