What is critique?

In this entry, you’ll learn how to examine the validity of premises. At the same time, you’ll understand what critique is.

Critical thinking in the narrow sense could be described as “how to build valid premises (premises that get a claim accepted as right).” Although this site takes a somewhat broader view of critical thinking, building valid premises is still essential.

You can’t build valid premises without knowing how their validity is examined. Since this is the first step, make sure you understand it well.

toc

How a Claim Gets Accepted

First, let’s sort out where premises stand in critical thinking. It comes down to two points:

  1. When there’s a question, what we want to decide is whether the claim is right
  2. To judge whether the claim is right, we examine the validity of the premises

Let’s check with an example.

bear

Should I buy a house or rent one?

panda

I think you should rent.

There are three reasons. First, buying property in Japan right now means you’re likely overpaying. Japan’s population will keep declining, so there will only be more and more surplus housing. In other words, as rents are likely to fall, it makes more sense to keep switching rentals to match.

Second… (omitted)

In critical thinking, jumping on the claim “you should rent” is forbidden. Examine the premises presented with the claim, and decide whether to accept the claim based on their validity.

Point

In critical thinking, you decide whether a claim is right by examining the validity of its premises

What It Means to Examine the Validity of Premises

So what exactly do you do to examine the validity of premises?

First, get a rough picture. Examining the validity of premises means stress-testing a building. The slide below sums it up.

根素主張•主張は一文しかない−主張の特性上、主張を複数の文で述べることはできない•根拠は複数の文で構成される−根拠を構成する個々の文を根素と呼ぶことにする(根拠の要素)•根素同士を、論理関係がつないでいる−論理関係=接続詞•根拠は根素の建築である−この建築物が主張を支えきれるなら、主張は正しいと考えるロジック=文の建築根拠ロジック(主張と根拠)の構成

As shown, an argument can be seen as a building made of sentences (statements and concepts).

Examining the validity of premises means stress-testing the green part of this building (the premises). You hit the pillars with a hammer, or even fire a bazooka at them. If the foundation still stands and the roof (the claim) remains, the claim is right.

The slide above is explained in detail in another entry. If what I’ve said so far doesn’t click, read the entry below before going further.

Stress-Testing = Critiquing

Of course, when you actually examine the validity of premises, you can’t use a hammer or a bazooka. Instead, you critique the premises.

Point

To examine the validity of premises, critique them

To critique is to examine for yourself whether the premises presented are really right. Instead of accepting the premises blindly, you think for yourself about whether you can accept them. In short, you doubt the premises.

Let’s check with the earlier example.

bear

Should I buy a house or rent one?

panda

I think you should rent.

There are three reasons. First, buying property in Japan right now means you’re likely overpaying. Japan’s population will keep declining, so there will only be more and more surplus housing. In other words, as rents are likely to fall, it makes more sense to keep switching rentals to match.

Second… (omitted)

Since Panda is the one presenting the argument, let’s have Bear critique the premises.

bear

Will Japan’s population really keep declining?

bear

Is the assumption that a declining population leads to lower property prices and rents actually right?

bear

Switching rentals means paying deposits and other fees. Is renting still cheaper even when you factor those in?

For example, even if “a declining population lowers property prices” is true in general, the population doesn’t decline uniformly across every region of Japan. Cities and rural areas lose population at different rates. So saying “Japanese property will fall in value” without narrowing down the region may be going too far.

Since we’re not actually trying to settle the question “Should I buy a house or rent one?”, let’s leave it at that.

What I want you to take away is the image of what it means to critique. Picture tapping the pillars with a hammer. By doubting each element of the premises in turn, you’re examining their rightness (stress-testing the premises).

Point

To critique: to examine for yourself whether the premises presented are really right

You Critique Even When Thinking Alone

Although the example above used two people in a discussion to make it easy to follow, the same applies when you’re thinking alone. Once you have an argument ready, have another version of yourself critique the premises.

If the premises withstand your own critique, you can share the argument with others. If they can’t, you either (1) change the claim, or (2) look for different premises. Going back and forth between claim and premises like this is what it means to think critically.

論点を設定するロジックを構築する根拠を批判する根拠は批判に耐え抜いたか?もうこの論点をギブアップしたいロジックの完成考えるYesNo根拠の強度テストをするとは|批判的に考えるとは

As an aside, this is exactly why the skill is called “critical thinking”1. Rather than accepting premises unconditionally, you always examine them critically yourself. By repeating this, you try to build more valid premises.

Critique in Its Original Sense Isn’t Negative

Note that “critique” here carries no negative meaning at all. Critique is indispensable for practicing critical thinking. It isn’t something you do out of negative feelings like “I don’t like that guy, so I’ll tear his argument apart.”

In other words, critiquing premises is a natural act. The only way to reach more valid premises (and the claims that come with them) is to critique premises.

In critical thinking, critique is simply a matter of proper method, or better yet, something driven by pure intellectual curiosity. Just because someone critiques your premises doesn’t mean they like or dislike you.

Some people misunderstand this. For them, “someone who critiques my premises (and ends up denying my claim) = an enemy.” Perhaps because of this, the everyday sense of “criticism” has come to mean almost the same thing as “slander,” at least in my impression. That’s truly unfortunate.

With that mindset, thinking with anyone becomes impossible. If you can’t critique premises, all you can do is affirm or deny claims. Whether to affirm or deny a claim is a matter of decision, unrelated to thinking. To think together with others, you need to critique premises and accept being critiqued as a matter of course.

Point

In critical thinking, critiquing premises is a natural act and carries no implication of personal attack

Of course, in reality, some people will critique your argument with the intent of a personal attack. And there’s no question that critiquing everything indiscriminately will strain your relationships. There are many situations where it’s better to stop critiquing and simply affirm (= empathize with) someone’s claim unconditionally.

Don’t forget to choose the people and situations where critique will lead to a constructive discussion.

What Are Valid Premises?

Let’s move on. As explained so far, premises are always exposed to critical scrutiny. If the premises presented withstand the critique “Can these premises really support the claim?”, the claim is accepted. If not, it isn’t.

This reveals what it means for premises to be valid. Valid premises are premises that withstand critique. If they withstand critique, the premises can support the claim. In other words, they were valid.

Point

Valid premises are premises that withstand critique

That means to build valid premises, you need to know how premises are critiqued. If you know what kind of attack is coming, you can prepare for it in advance. To build pillars that won’t break when hit with a hammer, learn how to use the hammer.

That covers how to examine the validity of premises. Next time, let’s learn specific ways to critique.

Entries related to critical thinking are collected on the page below. Feel free to use them as a reference.

Footnotes

  1. In Japan, the same skill is usually called “logical thinking.” Perhaps that’s because the Japanese translation of “critical” carries a strongly negative image. That said, some people in Japan treat “logical thinking” and “critical thinking” as separate skills. ↩