The three elements of rational decision-making

In this entry, you’ll learn what decision-making is and what elements it consists of.

Also, when you learn decision-making as a skill, you normally aim for rational decision-making. So we’ll also sort out how ordinary decision-making differs from rational decision-making.

There’s also a video version of this entry with almost the same content (in Japanese). It’s embedded at the end of this entry (you can jump to it from the table of contents).

Let’s begin.

toc

What Is Decision-Making?

This site defines decision-making as deciding what to do or what to regard as “right.” Roughly speaking, it’s answering a question that has no correct answer. Remember whichever you prefer.

Keyword

Decision-making: deciding what to do or what to regard as “right” (answering a question that has no correct answer)

Let’s look at some examples.

What you decideWhat you decided (example)
What should I wear today?I’ll wear a tracksuit.
What kind of clothes make it easier to focus on work?Clothes made of soft fabric.

The first decides what to do, and the second decides what to regard as “right.” Neither question has a correct answer. Acts like these are decision-making.

The Three Elements of a Decision

Next, let’s prepare a tool for analyzing decisions. Take a look at the slide below.

意思決定の3要素•意思決定は①論点、②結論、③理由の3要素で構成される−この言葉を使うと「意思決定とは、論点(問い)に対する結論を出すことである」と言い換えられる理由結論✓✓✓Why?!論点•意思決定すること−いま、何を意思決定したいのか?−意思決定とは何かを問うことなので、論点は必ず疑問文で書ける•意思決定の結果・論点に対する直接的な答え−最終的に、何をする・何を「正しい」とすることにしたのか?•その結論になった原因・根拠・経緯−なぜその結論になったのか?−理由が存在しない・言語化できない意思決定もある?

As shown, any decision consists of three elements:

  1. The question
  2. The conclusion
  3. The reason

Let me explain each in turn.

Element 1: The Question

First, the question is what you’re making a decision about. This is the starting point of any decision.

Keyword

The question: what you’re making a decision about (what, exactly, are you trying to decide right now?)

Let’s apply this term to the earlier table. Look at the headings.

QuestionWhat you decided (example)
What should I wear today?I’ll wear a tracksuit.
What kind of clothes make it easier to focus on work?Clothes made of soft fabric.

Much tidier.

Element 2: The Conclusion

Next, the conclusion is the result of a decision.

Keyword

The conclusion: the result of a decision

Let’s apply this to the table as well.

QuestionConclusion (example)
What should I wear today?I’ll wear a tracksuit.
What kind of clothes make it easier to focus on work?Clothes made of soft fabric.

Tidier still.

Element 3: The Reason

Finally, the reason is the background or basis behind the conclusion. Put simply, it explains why you reached that conclusion.

Keyword

The reason: the background or basis behind the conclusion (why you reached that conclusion)

Here’s the earlier table with reasons added.

QuestionConclusion (example)Reason (example)
What should I wear today?I’ll wear a tracksuit.It was within reach.
What kind of clothes make it easier to focus on work?Clothes made of soft fabric.That’s how it feels from experience.

Check that in both cases, the reason is the background or basis from which the conclusion was drawn.

Note that we aren’t yet concerned with the quality of the reasons, and not every decision needs a reason. Don’t get this wrong.

The Three Elements of “Rational” Decision-Making

As I said at the start, when you learn decision-making as a skill, you normally aim for rational decision-making. Think of “rational” here as meaning “right for everyone.”

Keyword

Rational: right for everyone

Although the three elements above (question, conclusion, and reason) are handy because they can describe any decision, they’re awkward when we limit ourselves to rational decision-making. So let’s update them as follows.

根拠主張(結論)論点•意思決定すること−これはそのまま変更しない•意思決定の結果・論点に対する直接的な答え−これが誰にとっても正しいものであることを目指す•主張が正しい理由−合理的な意思決定では、他者が主張の正しさを評価するための根拠が不可欠合理的な意思決定の3要素•合理的な意思決定では、論点に対するロジック(主張と根拠)を構築する−意思決定全般のケースと異なり、根拠がないことは認められない!?✓✓✓Why?ロジック

The slide looks similar to the previous one, but this is the one to remember. The changes are:

  1. “The question” stays the same
  2. “Conclusion” becomes “claim”
  3. “Reason” becomes “premises”

These three terms in bold are the key words for learning critical thinking (which on this site means “how to make rational decisions”). I’ll explain the details from the next entry onward, so for now, focus on grasping the overall structure and relationships.

Let me explain each in turn.

“The Question” Stays the Same

First, “the question” keeps the same meaning: what you’re making a decision about. Nothing changes.

“Conclusion” Becomes “Claim”

Here’s where things change. First, we’ll call the “conclusion” the “claim.”

The table below summarizes the difference in nuance between the two words. This is my interpretation, but I think most people would agree.

ConclusionClaim
Room for changeFeels settled (“it’s already been decided”)Feels open (“I want you to accept this as right”)
Presence of othersNot feltClearly present (a claim is normally directed at others)

When considering whether a decision is rational (right for everyone), it’s better to call the result of a decision a “claim.”

In rational decision-making, you aim for “a conclusion that everyone would accept as right.” In other words, think of your decision as exposed to the scrutiny of others rather than self-contained. Whether or not anyone actually scrutinizes it, you make your decision with that in mind.

Put another way, in rational decision-making, you look not for a self-serving “conclusion” but for a “claim” that everyone would accept as right.

Keyword

Claim: the result of a decision

Note, however, that in many contexts “conclusion” fits more naturally. I recommend treating “conclusion” and “claim” as synonyms, with “claim” as the default.

“Reason” Becomes “Premises”

Next, we replace “reason (why you reached that conclusion)” with “premises.”

Again, let’s start by comparing the two words. Take a look below.

ReasonPremises
MeaningCan refer to any factor behind a conclusion (background, cause, grounds, etc.)Limited to “why the conclusion is right”
OtherUsed in all sorts of contextsOften used alongside “claim”; carries a more formal tone

As you can see, premises are a type of reason, limited to the sense of “why something is right.”

If this explanation alone doesn’t click, read the link below (it jumps ahead in the learning order).

When you aim for rational decision-making, “premises” is clearly the better term. After all, you want to think about whether the claim is right.

Keyword

Premises: the reason a claim is right

Claim + Premises = Argument

Finally, we’ll call the pair of a claim and its premises, that is, the complete answer to the question, the “argument.” Here’s the slide again.

根拠主張(結論)論点•意思決定すること−これはそのまま変更しない•意思決定の結果・論点に対する直接的な答え−これが誰にとっても正しいものであることを目指す•主張が正しい理由−合理的な意思決定では、他者が主張の正しさを評価するための根拠が不可欠合理的な意思決定の3要素•合理的な意思決定では、論点に対するロジック(主張と根拠)を構築する−意思決定全般のケースと異なり、根拠がないことは認められない!?✓✓✓Why?ロジック

This is simply because it’s handy to have a word for the whole answer. When you actually analyze a decision, don’t lump them together as “the argument.” Always distinguish the claim from the premises.

Keyword

Argument: a claim and its premises (the complete answer to the question)

Note that in everyday English, “argument” often means a quarrel. That’s not what we mean here. Here, an argument is a claim supported by premises, the standard meaning in logic and critical thinking.

Using this term, let’s restate what thinking is: thinking means building an argument for the question you’ve set.

Point

Thinking means building an argument for the question you’ve set

Exercise

Let’s check what you’ve learned with an exercise. This one is a little harder.

Question

Identify the question, claim, and premises in the conversation below. Also, how could Panda make the point easier to follow?

bear
How can I lose three kilos by next month?
panda
Oh, I saw something on TV the other day. It’s a show that’s on Sundays at nine. It’s really fun, and I watch it every week. You should try the banana diet.
  • Question: How can I lose three kilos by next month?
  • Claim: You should try the banana diet
  • Premises: A TV show I enjoy and watch every week said so

To make Panda easier to follow, two problems need fixing: (1) the premises are hard to follow, and (2) the claim comes last.

One improvement is to put the claim first: “You should try the banana diet. A TV show I enjoy and watch every week said so.” That’s much easier to follow.

However, it’s doubtful whether these premises are valid (= whether the claim can be accepted as rational). That’s what we’ll study from here.

Summary

Finally, take one more look at the slide.

根拠主張(結論)論点•意思決定すること−これはそのまま変更しない•意思決定の結果・論点に対する直接的な答え−これが誰にとっても正しいものであることを目指す•主張が正しい理由−合理的な意思決定では、他者が主張の正しさを評価するための根拠が不可欠合理的な意思決定の3要素•合理的な意思決定では、論点に対するロジック(主張と根拠)を構築する−意思決定全般のケースと異なり、根拠がないことは認められない!?✓✓✓Why?ロジック

Whenever you make a decision (think about a question that has no correct answer), always keep these three elements in mind: the question, the claim, and premises. That alone should help you think much better than before.

That covers the three elements of decision-making. From here, let’s dig deeper into each element. Continue to the entry below.

Entries related to critical thinking are collected on the page below. Feel free to use them as a reference.

Learn or Review with the Video

Here’s the video mentioned at the start (in Japanese). Although the content isn’t exactly the same, the main points are.